Restaurants

The Boardwalk Family of Restaurants

Enjoy dining at either of the Boardwalk’s two waterfront restaurants, where our Famous Lobster Bisque is always a featured favorite!

The Boardwalk Main Deck offers plenty of indoor and outdoor seating with spectacular views of the Put-in-Bay Harbor. Three distinct food concessions where you place your order right at the counter. Alaskan King Crab,Key West Shrimp, Grilled Fish Sandwiches, Burgers and Fresh Lake Erie Perch and Walleye! Or rent one of outside decks or bars for your company outing or other event.

The Boardwalk’s Upper Deck offers table side service in air-conditioned comfort with panoramic views of the downtown harbor. We offer plenty of seating, and a professional staff to host your special event. Whether it is a rehearsal dinner, company outing or wedding, we have the right option for you. We feature a full menu, including Gluten Free and Vegetarian options that can be tailored to fit your needs. Hand-shaken Martini’s, Specialty Cocktails and a large Wine list are available to tempt your guests.

We do limit reservations to 12 and above, and can’t guarantee reservations on weekends or holidays. Call our Event Coordinator to start planning your event now.

THE BOARDWALK FAMILY OF RESTAURANTS
Bay View Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-3695
the-boardwalk.com
Map Location 12

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Boathouse Bar & Grill

The Boathouse has been an island landmark since the 1950’s. The Boathouse’s menu includes Lake Erie perch, and walleye, & Southern style food with family friendly prices. They also have a menu just for kids. Diners can sit outside and enjoy the outdoor patio that lines the front and wraps around the side of the building. The front of the Boathouse opens up and diners can also enjoy the outdoors while indoors. The bar also features a large stage and is a popular venue for live bands and entertainment. Kick back and enjoy casual, comfortable surroundings and allow stellar staff to treat you to the best culinary experience on Put-in-Bay.

BOATHOUSE BAR & GRILL
Hartford Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-5665
theboathousebarandgrill.com
Map Location 20

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Cameo Pizza

Put-in-Bay’s Cameo Pizza is located inside Mr. Ed Bar and Grill.  Cameo, based in Sandusky, Ohio, has been making great pizza since 1936. Cameo’s features a selection of pizza specials, including their famous sauerkraut pizza, pizza by the slice, wings, salads, and sub sandwiches. Cameo’s offers free delivery on the island. You can also dine in or carry out your order. Open daily 11:30 a.m. to 3:30 a.m. with delivery until 3 a.m.

CAMEO PIZZA
Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-4444
Map Location 21
Map Location 10

Crews Nest Catering

Enjoy your Island Wedding Reception at Put-in-Bay’s only private club. The Crew’s Nest will cater your reception at their secluded pavilion, The Doller House Mansion or an island site of your choice. Beautiful grounds and exceptional food. Sites located on and near the waterfront, just a short walk from the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay.

CREW’S NEST CATERING
Bay View AvenueThe Crews Nest offers catering services on and off premise
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-3625
thecrewsnest.com
Map Location 23

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

The Chicken Patio

Winner, Winner we have island wine basted BBQ Chicken Dinners. A local favorite. The Chicken Patio is adjacent to the Round House Bar and Park Hotel, in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay. Serving up island basted BBQ chicken dinners with corn on the cob, potato salad and dinner roll. Affordable and family friendly (including your family pet). Outdood patio is a great place to relax and enjoy DeRivera Park & downtown harbor. Open for late night dinners Fri/Sat during season. You’re a winner with this island favorite dinner.

CHICKEN PATIO
Delaware Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-3581
chickenpatio.com
Map Location 21

out-door-seating-icon

Dairy Isle

Located just steps away from the Jet Express, the Dairy Isle is a great spot for anyone looking for a fast meal at an affordable price! Our Burgers and Fresh Lake Erie Perch Sandwiches are favorites of tourists and Islanders alike. Visit the Dairy Isle and enjoy one of our homemade Waffle Cones, or a Flurry with your favorite treat swirlled right in. Or try one of our Fresh Smoothies or Ice Cream Coffee drinks. We offer iced flavored coffees as well. Our menu is family friendly, and hard to beat! Schedule your next school group or company outing by calling our event coordinator today to schedule a time convenient for you.

You scream, I scream, we all scream for Ice Cream!

DAIRY ISLE
Bay View Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 23

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-icon

The Dollar Mansion

The Historic Victorian, Italianate Doller Mansion built and owned by Valentine Doller, an Island Entrepreneur and former mayor of Put-In-Bay, was built between 1866 and 1885 and is an excellent venue for your next social event. The large lakeside front yard offers a panoramic view for parties up to 400 that few are likely to forget. The picturesque gazebo located in the backyard is ideal for large events. The vast backyard makes plenty of dancing and socializing room for receptions, company picnics/outings, and family reunions. Planning something smaller? Have an intimate birthday, cocktail or dinner party inside this historic home for as few as 15 guests or as large as 60 guests.

PUT-IN-BAY WINERY
AT THE DOLLER ESTATE
Bay View Avenue
419-285-3343
putinbaywinery.com

Map Location 12

The Fish Bowl

Looking for a fun, relaxed atmosphere? Try The Fishbowl for lunch or dinner. Their menu features fresh 1/2 pound burgers, Lake Erie perch and walleye, homemade soups, sandwiches, wings, and salads. Also, serving a late night menu.

THE FISH BOWL
371 Catawba Ave
Put-in-Bay, Ohio

419-285-8888
www.mossbacksatputinbay.com
Map Location 24

waterfront-icon

The Forge

Located in the remodeled blacksmith shop, The Forge brings something new to Put-In-Bay’s downtown restaurant district. Beyond their famous crêpes and carefully crafted espresso drinks, they provide the perfect menu and atmosphere for brunch, lunch and dinner. Their outside patio is home to The Garden Bar, the perfect hidden summer spot to enjoy craft cocktails and live entertainment.

THE FORGE
Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-0022
theoldforgepib.com
Map Location 33

out-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Frosty Bar & Family Pizza

Located in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay, Frosty’s has been an island tradition for 60 years. Cold beer served in the signature frosty beer mug, peanut shells crunching underfoot, tasty pizza baked fresh to order, and classic rock tunes from the jukebox are all part of what makes Frosty’s a favorite. Native islanders, boaters, and day trippers alike flock to Frosty’s for the beautiful view of DeRivera Park and the Put-in-Bay harbor.

FROSTY BAR & FAMILY PIZZA
Delaware Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-3278
frostys.com
Map Location 25

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-icon

The Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern

Located between the church and the winery, The Goat Soup & Whiskey Tavern provides a calm oasis from the bustling of downtown. Outstanding comfort food is served in a beautiful setting that was once an original island winery. All the wonderful soups and sauces are made from scratch daily. Enjoy everything from meatloaf to walleye, or try the original perch taco. The Goat accommodates groups and special events on premise only.

THE GOAT SOUP & WHISKEY TAVERN
820 Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
The Goat

419-285-4628
soupandwhiskey.com
Map Location 26

Heineman Winery

Heineman Winery is included here because the winery serves cheese trays, and snacks with a variety of island wines and grape juice. They do not serve sandwiches, or any other food items. Sample wines and purchase a bottle or a gift pack of island wine for home. Wines have consistently won gold, silver and bronze medals in competition. Nice wine Garden, gift shop and tour.

HEINEMAN WINERY
978 Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-2811
heinemanswinery.com
Map Location 3

out-door-seating-icon

Hooligan’s

Hooligan’s is a full service restaurant and bar featuring a pub-style menu. Home-made Irish favorites like Reuben sandwiches, Fish & Chips, Shepherd’s Pie, Guinness Wings, Irish Nachos, Irish Cheese sampler, Specialty burgers, Fresh Salads and Inventive Sandwiches are also offered. Marie’s Hooley Cheese Dip is a MUST HAVE and an Islander Favorite!

Relax with friends and family on Hooligan’s beautiful front porch overlooking Catawba Avenue while enjoying a delicious meal, or a pint of Guinness. Hooligan’s features a large selection of craft and Irish beers on draught. Top Irish entertainers from the Midwest keep things lively on Friday and Saturday evenings from June through October! Hooligan’s is the proud sponsor of Put-in-Bay’s Half-Way to St. Patty’s Day Parade! Slainte!

HOOLIGAN’S
Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-8000
hooliganspib.com
Map Location 27

out-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

The Keys

The Keys is a full service Florida Keys themed restaurant with 4 distinct locations to satisfy your needs: Tortuga’s Rum Republic, Lola’s Key, Hemmingway’s and the Tiki Shak showcasing Caribbean fare! Fresh Seafood to Conch Chowder, Key West Shrimp, burgers, tropical salads and sandwiches. We can create a menu tailored specifically for your group, and we have a location to fit any of your needs. Gluten Free and Vegetarian items are also available.

The Keys is located in downtown Put-in-Bay just steps away from the Jet Express, with unparalleled views of the Harbor and Perry’s Monument. Call us today to start planning your special event with our event coordinator. We do limit reservations to 12 and above, and can’t guarantee any reservations on weekends or holidays.

THE KEYS
Bay View Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-5397
thekeyspib.com 
Map Location 30

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Mama Maria's Pizza

Nothing quite hits the spot after a late night like one of Mama Maria’s homemade meatball sandwiches or a slice of gooey cheese pizza. Luckily, Mama Maria knows we crave her cooking at all hours of the day and night, so her place stays open as late as the bars (or later). The patio makes for a great place to take in the view of the harbor and downtown Putinbay at any time.

MAMA MARIA’S PIZZA
266 Delaware Ave
Put-in-Bay, Ohio

419-285-7400
Map Location 75

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-icon

Margaritas
on the Rock

Beginning its first year of operation, Margaritas on the Rock is excited to announce more details of what’s to come this 2018 Summer Season. Margaritas on the Rock will be showcasing a wide variety of hand-crafted and thoughtfully designed margaritas, cocktails and frozen blends. Using fresh ingredients and 100% Agave tequila, there’s a drink for everyone on the Rock. A brand new menu is a refreshing mix of Southwest American food, Island favorites and fresh, healthy options. Our menu will have even more affordable and recognizable choices for all palettes.  Margaritas on the Rock will be having a Grand Opening on Memorial Day Weekend with a soft opening before. Visit us at 185 Toledo Ave (directly across from the Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial) to check out the newest bar and restaurant in Put-in-Bay, OH’s historic downtown district and grab a margarita before all the Spicy Senoritas are gone!

Coming Soon: We’ll be announcing our new website and live entertainment schedule.

MARGARITAS ON THE ROCKS
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 18

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Mossback's

Mossbacks is located at the corner of Catawba & Bayview Avenues and serves a pub style menu that features fresh, hand-breaded Lake Erie perch as well as great hamburgers, sandwiches, homemade soups, salads, and sides. Well known for their sauerkraut balls, Mossback’s also serves up a German food special in October that includes sausages, kraut, German potato salad, potato pancakes, and German Chocolate cake. Let Mossback’s kitchen put together a menu for your next event.

MOSSBACK’S
Catawba & Bay View Avenues
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-8888
mossbacksatputinbay.com

Map Location 24

waterfront-icon

Pasquale’s Cafe

Pasquale’s Cafe, located on the corner of Loraine and Delaware Avenues, serves breakfast, lunch and dinner in a relaxed setting. Pasquale’s serves a full service breakfast, and also features a lunch and dinner menu of Italian favorites and pizza. Pasquale’s Cafe offers a full complement of catering services, from box lunches to party platters. Pasquale’s can custom design a menu just for you for your next event.

PASQUALE’S CAFE
Delaware Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-8600
pasqualescafe.com

Map Location 34

waterfront-icon

Put-in-Bay Brewery & Distillery

The Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery is located in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay. Sip on a fresh beer brewed right here on the island while enjoying one of their specialty hand-tossed pizzas. They pride themselves in being Put-in-Bay’s first legal distillery, so take home a unique bottle of Island Rum or Island Vodka. Check out the patio bar where they offer a fine selection of hand-crafted bourbons. Great food at a great price, plus a friendly Brew Crew! Kitchen open until 11 PM.

PUT-IN-BAY BREWERY & DISTILLERY
441 Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-4677
putinbaybrewery.com
Map Location 36

out-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Reel Bar

On a Reel Bar T-shirt you will find (b:1906, rb:2014). What does it mean? The bar was built in 1906, but was re-built in 2014 when it re-opened as Reel Bar. Formerly the location of the beloved Tony’s Place, Reel Bar pays homage to it history with its décor and Great Lakes Island Theme. They now serve breakfast, lunch dinner and late night snacks. On the menu you can find creative appetizers, fish, fresh salads and the famous Reel Burger! Wash it down with 16 draft beers, fresh squeezed cocktails and over 30 fine bourbons! The intimate stage has helped Reel Bar to be voted PIB’s Favorite Entertainment Venue 3 years straight! And Reel Bar offers a great catering service for your private party. Reel Food, Reel Music, Reel Fun!

REEL BAR
461 Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
reelbar.com
Map Location 36

out-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

The Sand Bar

Located at the Adventure Bay complex off of Main Street, The Sand Bar is your favorite fun pool bar with all the amenities you would expect and then some. We offer a large Tiki style bar completely surrounded by white Florida Beach Sand. Beach volleyball, corn hole, pool games, cabanas, and a great menu will keep you happy all day long.

THE SAND BAR
407 Langram Rd.
Put-in-Bay, Ohio

419-341-4716
www.putinbaysandbar.com
Map Location 32

out-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Topsy Turvey’s Island Bar & Grill

Topsy Turvey’s is located inside the Wharfside, adjacent to the Boardwalk and across from Mossback’s. Topsy Turvey is a fun, local hang-out with an outside deck overlooking the Bay. Home of the island’s Cuban sandwich, this small island eatery is big on producing good food and lots of fun. Open 7 days a week during the season and throughout the off-season Thursday through Sunday.

TOPSY TURVEY’S ISLAND BAR & GRILLE
Bay View Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-4511
topsyturveys.com
Map Location 37

waterfront-iconout-door-seating-iconlive-entertainment-icon

Village Bakery

The Village Bakery specializes in made from scratch catering. Coffee is fresh ground daily and all pastries are homemade. The menu offers bagels, muffins, cinnamon rolls, cookies, fresh fruit, and danishes just to name a few. The Village Bakery specializes in cakes of all sizes and types, including wedding, birthday, anniversary and other special occasion cakes, cupcakes and cheesecakes. The homemade pie menu includes blueberry, apple, lemon meringue, strawberry-custard, french silk and many others. The catering menu consists of full or continental breakfast, deli trays, box lunches for boat charters or school groups, lunch and dinner entrees, and of course desserts. Delivery to you special event is also available.

VILLAGE BAKERY
104 Delaware Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-5351
villagebakerypib.com
Map Location 19

X
Skip to toolbar