Red Moon
Step into the captivating allure of the Red Moon, Put-in-Bay’s exclusive speakeasy and a hidden gem nestled beside the historic Park Hotel. Since opening in June 2015, Red Moon has remained an island secret, drawing guests under the warm glow of the red light for intimate cocktails, whispered conversations, and vintage ambiance unlike anywhere else.
Put-in-Bay Brewery & Distillery
Located in downtown Put-in-Bay, the Brewery & Distillery is the island’s go-to for fresh, locally brewed beer and house-made spirits. Enjoy hand-tossed specialty pizzas, seasonal brews, and classic pub fare in a relaxed setting that captures the island’s laid-back vibe.
Mossbacks
Located at Catawba & Bayview, Mossbacks is a cozy tavern serving up a pub-style menu with Lake Erie perch, hearty burgers, sandwiches, homemade soups, fresh salads, and classic sides. With a welcoming vibe and quality comfort food, it’s a go-to spot for casual island dining.
Mojito Bay
Mojito Bay delivers tropical vibes with sand floors, a full bar, and freshly muddled mojitos. Kick off your shoes, enjoy live island music, play Cornhole or Giant Jenga, and soak in the beachy atmosphere. Friendly staff, festive lights, great energy, and laughter make it unforgettable.
Joe’s Bar & Restaurant
Joe’s Bar & Restaurant is a local favorite set in the historic Press House Market near South Bass Island State Park. It’s the perfect laid-back spot to grab a cold drink or bite after golfing or exploring, with a welcoming atmosphere, classic island charm, and great daily specials.
Hooligans Irish Pub
Hooligans is a lively Irish pub offering hearty favorites like Reubens, Fish & Chips, Shepherd’s Pie, Irish Nachos, burgers, and more. Don’t miss Marie’s Hooley Cheese Dip—an island favorite! Enjoy fresh salads, craft drinks, and great vibes with friendly local service.
Goat Soup and Whiskey Tavern
Located between the church and the winery, The Goat Soup and Whiskey Tavern provides a calm oasis from the bustling of downtown. Outstanding comfort food is served in a beautiful setting that was once an original island winery.
Cameo Pizza
A family favorite since 1936, Cameo Pizza serves up legendary pies like Chicken Bacon Ranch from its spot inside Mr. Ed’s. Enjoy fresh dough and sauce made daily, dine-in or carry out, or grab a late-night slice at the window. Open daily with delivery until 3 a.m. across the island.
Boathouse Bar & Grill
A Put-in-Bay staple since the 1950s, The Boathouse serves Lake Erie perch, walleye, and Southern-style comfort food at family-friendly prices. Enjoy outdoor or open-air dining, a kid’s menu, and live music on the big stage, great food, drinks, and atmosphere in the heart of downtown.
Boardwalk Main Deck & Upper Deck
Enjoy dining at The Boardwalk’s two waterfront restaurants featuring Lobster Bisque, seafood favorites, burgers, and cocktails. The Main Deck has casual counter service with patio seating. The Upper Deck offers table service, air conditioning, and harbor views.