Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum
Whether you’re a history buff or just curious about Put-in-Bay’s past, the Lake Erie Islands Historical Society Museum is a must-visit attraction for all ages!
The Bell Buoy Gifts
Your one-stop shop at Put-in-Bay! The Bell Buoy offers gifts & souvenirs, while The Boathouse Beverage Center has beer, wine, snacks & more.
Country House Gifts
Country House Gifts is Put-in-Bay largest gift store, located in center of downtown on Delaware Ave. Come take a stroll through one of Put-in-Bay’s historic buildings that is full of island treasures and keepsakes.
Put-in-Bay Surf Shop
Put-in-Bay Surf Shop is your go-to for name-brand island wear like Roxy, Quiksilver, O’Neill, Reef, and Billabong. Explore a full range of beach-ready gear from swimsuits and sunglasses to stickers, longboards, and exclusive Mojito Bay apparel.
Misty Bay Boutique
Misty Bay Boutique brings you the latest in women’s resort fashion with brands like Lulu B and Sperry. Shop swimwear, sundresses, sunglasses, and beach accessories in a relaxed, pet-friendly space next to the Round House patio bar. A must-visit for Lake Erie vacation style.
Local Color
Feel the island vibes at Local Color, located at The Keys near The Dairy Isle. Shop local artist prints, coastal gifts, mermaid trinkets, and custom dog gear. Don’t miss the Sticker Shak—buy 4, get 1 free! Grab a Starbucks coffee and explore their unique mix of beachwear and souvenirs.
Dockside Gifts
Dockside Gifts, located at the Miller Ferry Lime Kiln Dock, is the perfect first and last stop on your Put-in-Bay visit. This inviting shop offers a great selection of Put-in-Bay t-shirts, sweatshirts, handcrafted jewelry, unique home décor, and thoughtful souvenirs—something for every traveler to take home.
Carriage House
The Carriage House is Put-in-Bay’s largest downtown gift shop. Located on Delaware Ave, it offers souvenirs, apparel up to 5XL, toys, pet items, home goods, and taffy. With something for everyone and helpful staff, it’s a must-visit stop for memorable gifts, keepsakes and heirlooms.
Bucket Shop
Discover unique gifts at The Bucket Shop inside the Round House Bar. Shop tees, hats, koozies, pet gear, and fun souvenirs that celebrate Put-in-Bay’s most iconic watering hole. Whether you’re shopping for yourself or a gift, it’s your go-to spot for island flair.