The Keys Put-in-Bay
The Keys is a vibrant, Florida Keys-themed spot with waterfront views and multiple dining areas. From seafood and sushi to tropical cocktails and hand-shaken lemonades, enjoy great food, drinks, and live entertainment with Perry’s Monument as your backdrop.
Mossbacks
Located at Catawba & Bayview, Mossbacks is a cozy tavern serving up a pub-style menu with Lake Erie perch, hearty burgers, sandwiches, homemade soups, fresh salads, and classic sides. With a welcoming vibe and quality comfort food, it’s a go-to spot for casual island dining.
Hooligans Irish Pub
Hooligans is a lively Irish pub offering hearty favorites like Reubens, Fish & Chips, Shepherd’s Pie, Irish Nachos, burgers, and more. Don’t miss Marie’s Hooley Cheese Dip—an island favorite! Enjoy fresh salads, craft drinks, and great vibes with friendly local service.
Goat Soup and Whiskey Tavern
Located between the church and the winery, The Goat Soup and Whiskey Tavern provides a calm oasis from the bustling of downtown. Outstanding comfort food is served in a beautiful setting that was once an original island winery.
Boathouse Bar & Grill
A Put-in-Bay staple since the 1950s, The Boathouse serves Lake Erie perch, walleye, and Southern-style comfort food at family-friendly prices. Enjoy outdoor or open-air dining, a kid’s menu, and live music on the big stage, great food, drinks, and atmosphere in the heart of downtown.
Boardwalk Main Deck & Upper Deck
Enjoy dining at The Boardwalk’s two waterfront restaurants featuring Lobster Bisque, seafood favorites, burgers, and cocktails. The Main Deck has casual counter service with patio seating. The Upper Deck offers table service, air conditioning, and harbor views.