Cottages, Private Homes & Condos

Ohio House

The All-Star Ohio House is an historical, entertaining family, and group friendly rental home located 200 feet from downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio. Six bedrooms and three bathrooms accommodate up to 22 guests. A/C, Direct TV, Gas BBQ, corn hole, private backyard. Sheets, towels and linens are provided, Guests also enjoy use of Put-in-Bay Resorts pool and swim up bar, just 500 feet away. An island favorite for groups and family reunions.

394 Loraine avenue, Put-in-Bay OH 43456
Map Location 55

A Place At The Bay

A Place at the Bay has four bedrooms, two full baths and a Jacuzzi master suite that accommodates up to 12 people. Located on 1.5 acres on Put-in-Bay Road, across from the entrance to the Island Club. Fully equipped kitchen, wooded lot, near the South Bass Island State Park and boat access to Lake Erie. Pool privleges for all guests nearby.

1559 Jeris Lane
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 59

Aunt Mary's Place

This large, historic island home is located on Toledo Avenue, on the edge of the three-block downtown district of the Village of Put-in-Bay. The home has an open dining and living space that was designed for entertaining. It has four bedrooms, a newly renovated full bath with shower, and a half bath.  It can accommodate up to 10 people.When it’s time to relax, and kick back, the Queen Elizabeth has a large, full-screened enclosed back porch that overlooks the National Park, and the memorial column. To reserve your week, or weekend for your Put-in-Bay island escape this summer, call 216-870-1098.

207 Toledo Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Immediately next to
Map Location 112

Bay Club Cottages

Quaint island cottages on Bath Street just a half a block from Put-in-Bay’s downtown on the lake with a picturesque view of the lake and Kelleys Island. Weekend, weekday or weekly rental. Great for families, friends and fishermen.

Bath Street
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 62

Back Bay Condos C & D

Two one-bedroom lakefront condos located on the second floor of Back Bay Condominiums. A short walk to downtown. Wonderful views of the lakefront, the Perry Memorial, and Kelleys Island. Accommodates up to four people, fully equipped kitchen, TV, AC, stereo, king bed. Convenient location, and spectacular sunrises and lake views. Picnic table, and grill, and a spacious second floor balcony to enjoy breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a good book. You can also email us ebaek @ or call 419-261-3147.

348 Toledo Avenue #D
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 52

Blue Sky Rentals (also suites)

Blue Sky Rentals has two houses for rent on Put-in-Bay.  The Westwind is Put-in-Bay’s premier lakefront rental property. Located on West Shore Blvd, the Westwind is 1500 sq ft of fabulous living space. With a large front porch and a 30′ by 20′ deck on the lakefront with spectacular views of Lake Erie and sensational sunsets.  The Lighthouse is a beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 full bath, fully furnished home, nicely appointed with an excellent interior layout. Features include a patio with a grill, picnic tables and patio chairs for outdoor grilling/lounging and pool access which is across the street from the Lighthouse.

West Shore
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 63

Cantillon's Poor
Man's Nantucket

Poor Man’s Nantucket is located on a quiet lane on South Bass Island’s East Point. The Salt Box home sits on one acre of landscaped yard and has two bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths, central A/C, finished basement living area, loft, w/b fireplace, Jacuzzi, two decks, screened porch. Sleeps 6. Rented weekly.

Mike’s Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 64

Casual Cape & Guest House

This charming Cape Cod cottage has four bedrooms, three full baths and sleeps up to 12 people. The guest house sleeps up to six. Lots of room, large landscaped lot. Great for family vacations. TV with cable, VCR, fully equipped kitchens, grills, outdoor eating and entertaining area, and more.

Mike’s Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 65

Harbour Square Suites

Within a 15-minute walk of Stonehenge and Aquatic Resource Center, Harbour Square Suites is a great choice if you want to stay in South Bass Island. Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial and Lake Erie Islands Historical Society are also within a short walk of this property.

Unwind in one of the 3 pleasant condos, where you can take advantage of sofa beds, living rooms and coffee makers. You’ll also appreciate the kitchenette, flat-screen TV with satellite channels and desk. Limited housekeeping is available.

A perfect base for exploring Put-in-Bay, this property provides a restaurant, a bar/lounge and a garden.

185 Toledo Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 18

Island Club Resort

The Island Club is a private community renting 3-bedroom homes for 8, 10, and 12 persons. Midweek specials are available. Each unit has a fully equipped kitchen, A/C, living area, color TV, two full baths, gas grill, and private decks. There is a pool onsite, open daily during the season.

1490 Put-in-Bay Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 77

Put-in-Bay Cabins

Put-in-Bay Cabins offer a 2 or 3 bedroom cabin, or both , fully furnished with fully equipped kitchens.  Put-in-Bay Cabins are located on a quiet lane on East Point. Trees surround each cabin which adds to the relaxing atmosphere. Both cabins have decks, gas grills, and picnic tables. There are private campfire rings provided for each cabin for sitting around a campfire in the evenings,and there are horseshoe pits, and a volleyball net for those wanting a little activity. Perry’s Monument is with in walking distance. The shops, and Put-in-Bay’s other attractions are just a short ride away.

141 Massie Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 70

Put-in-Bay Condos

Eight two-bedroom condo units overlooking the waterfront with a view of the mainland and islands can accommodate up to 8 people. Both bedrooms have either two full or two queen beds and the living room has a pull-out sofa. Two baths, lots of closet space, washer/dryer, AC and fully equipped kitchen with microwave, full sized refrigerators and ice makers. Beautiful pool with nice deck for sunbathing surrounded by a large green lawn, all on 500 feet of obscured lakefront. Sand beach and lots of off-street parking with room to accommodate a boat and trailer. Plenty of room to stretch out and relax.

1240 Tri-Motor Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 76

Put-in-Bay House

Two eight-person suites in a duplex with an adjoining locking door that can accommodate your entire family. Each unit has a full kitchen and two full baths, private porch. Great for family reunions and “bachelorette” parties. Private one acre setting. Located near the Island Club.

770 Evelyn Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Map Location 59

Rays By The Bay

This lakefront cottage in a quiet, close to town neighborhood sleeps 6. Back Bay view of Perry’s Monument and Marblehead.
Cottage features: screened front porch, living room, 2 bedrooms,
1 bathroom (shower only), full kitchen and a beautiful sun room for dining with a lake view. A rear deck with picnic tables and a gas grill.

Adjacent to the cottage is a park area with playground for small children and a dock for sunning, swimming and fishing. No overnight dockage allowed. No smoking or pets.

For more information you can contact Maureen or Ray Dinallo at
440-248-6637, or 440-915-6263, or

130 Chapman RD
Put-In-Bay, Ohio, 43456

Skip to toolbar