Shopping

Discover unique keepsakes at The Bucket Shop, the go-to gift store nestled inside the iconic Round House Bar on Delaware Ave. Celebrating your favorite island watering hole, our shop boasts an eclectic selection of Round House Bar-themed souvenirs. From stylish tees, cozy sweatshirts, and trendy tanks to fashionable hats and fun socks, there's something for everyone. Don't miss our array of koozies, drinkware, and pet gear that captures the spirit of island life. Whether you're looking for a memento for yourself or a special gift, The Bucket Shop is your destination for distinctive Round House Bar memorabilia. Stop by to explore our treasures and take home a piece of the island's vibrant charm!

Put-in-Bay’s Butterfly House at the Perry’s Cave Family Fun Center offers visitors a unique viewing experience of hundreds of different exotic butterflies in their beautiful atrium filled with plants, fountains and sculptures. The butterflies on display are not native to the United States and precautions are used so they cannot escape their home in the atrium. Visitors walk amongst the butterflies and can purchase butterfly specimens and posters in the gift shop to help remember their trip.

The Carriage House is the island’s largest downtown gift shop. Located on Delaware Ave, next to the Carousel, this shop offers hundreds of island souvenirs and apparel. Clothing selections range from 6 months to 5XL, and to accessorize your apparel they have summer purses and totes, hats, sunglasses and much more. Children love the stuffed animals and other fun toys. Don’t forget your pet! There are many fun and unique items to choose from for Fido.  Along with home décor items, greeting cards, drink tumblers and gifts for men; our friendly, helpful clerks are sure to help you find something perfect for everyone in your family.

Compass Pointe is your island shopping destination! With five stores and plenty of parking, you’ll enjoy browsing a wide variety of options. From nautical gifts and decor, to jewelry, men’s and women’s resort wear, and even unique Put-in-Bay souvenirs and Christmas ornaments–you’ll find something for everyone at Compass Pointe!

Country House Gifts is Put-in-Bay largest gift store, located in center of downtown on Delaware Ave. Come take a stroll through one of Put-in-Bay’s historic buildings that is full of island treasures and keepsakes. We specialize in nautical themed home decor. If you are shopping for the family we have a wide selection of souvenirs, apparel and accessories for all ages. We love to showcase our local artists and local authors.

Located at the Miller Ferry Put-in-Bay Lime Kiln dock, Dockside Gifts has all of your souvenir needs. From Put-in-Bay t-shirts and sweatshirts to unique house wears to handcrafted jewelry, Dockside has something for everyone! Make this your first and last stop shop on the island.

Heineman's Winery, deeply rooted in the heritage of Put-in-Bay, has been an emblem of winemaking excellence since its establishment in 1888 by Gustav Heineman. The winery continues to thrive under the stewardship of Gustav's great-great-grandson, Dustin Heineman, who carries the torch of this family legacy with pride and dedication.

The memory of Louis and Edward Heineman, who were pivotal in the winery's story until their passing, is honored and cherished. Their passion and influence remain integral to the winery's spirit and guide its future.

Offering tours from May through October, the winery provides a journey through the fascinating Crystal Cave and the art of viticulture. Following the tour, guests are invited to enjoy a complimentary tasting of wine or grape juice, showcasing the unique flavors developed from the island's vineyards.

Visitors can relax in the wine garden, sipping on a selection from over 21 different wines produced on-site, including the exquisite ice wine—a testament to Heineman's winemaking prowess. The garden offers a peaceful setting to enjoy a platter of cheese, fruit, and crackers, perfectly paired with their wines.

As a tribute to its history and a toast to its future, Heineman’s Winery invites connoisseurs and novices alike to share in the experience of local winemaking. For more about the winery's history, offerings, and to plan your visit, explore their website at heinemanswinery.com. Step into the story of the Heineman family with each glass of wine, a blend of tradition, and the essence of Put-in-Bay.

The Lake Erie Islands Historical Society Heritage Antique Shop offers a glimpse into Put-in-Bay’s past. The resale and thrift Shop is located behind the Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum next to the Put-in-Bay Town Hall just off of Catawba Ave. It’s an endless treasure hunt! New Items added daily. Open daily, May through September.

Discover a world of convenience at the Island General Store, strategically situated on Catawba Avenue, your one-stop destination for all your island grocery essentials. Whether you're in need of freshly cut meats, ripe produce, a variety of deli selections, or essential dry goods, our store caters to all your needs year-round. We pride ourselves on offering a wide range of high-quality items that make island living easy and enjoyable. Step in for a delightful shopping experience where friendly service and a diverse selection await to fulfill your every culinary desire, whether you're a local resident or a visiting guest. The Island General Store is more than just a grocery shop; it's a vital part of the Put-in-Bay community, ensuring that everything you need is just a short walk away.

Put-in-Bay's One stop shopping destination! From beer, wine, and ice to quality meats and fresh produce, to marine and automotive supplies, home repair needs and more; we've got everything you're looking for...even ample free parking!

Jessie's Jewelry offers beautiful custom jewelry that's one of a kind, just like you! A piece of jewelry can be more than just a beautiful accessory. Instead, it can represent a powerful emotional connection to a person, symbolize a relationship, or simply remind the wearer of a cherished memory. While jewelry can be worn daily, there’s a new category of accessories that never have to be taken off, Permanent jewelry! Stop by the Keyosk and ask about our Permanent Jewelry service at Put-in-Bay. Also available for pop-ups and special events.

Lake Effects Boutique offers a curated collection of elevated coastal casual women’s apparel, accessories and jewelry. Whether you're looking for a new outfit for your next summer soiree, or a shopping experience with all your besties, we've got you covered. Find gorgeous tarnish-proof jewelry, of-the-moment styles and gorgeous gifts. Located in downtown Put-in-Bay on Delaware Avenue next to the Carriage House and Carousel, this is a must stop for the discerning shopper seeking women’s clothing, accessories and gifts.

The Lobster Trap features unique souvenir items, and resort apparel as well as the Boardwalk’s private label bloody mary mix and hot sauce. Also visit for custom sportswear, island tees, and nautical decor. It’s small in size but big in selection!

Feel the tropical vibes of Local Color t-shirts & treasures. Located at The Keys restaurant just West of The Dairy Isle. This shop features local artist prints, resort apparel, custom dog gear, mermaids for all ages, coastal jewelry, and a unique variety of t-shirts. Don’t leave the island without taking home an original designed sticker from our Sticker Shak (buy 4 – get 5th free). We also sell freshly brewed Starbucks coffee.

Mariner’s Locker carries a variety of men’s clothing and shoes. Whether he needs something for a night out, a fishing trip, or just a causal outing, it can be found here. We also have men’s and women’s souvenir t-shirts and sweatshirts. Some of our most popular brands are Sperry, Columbia, and Old Guys Rule. You do not want to miss this store!

Misty Bay Boutique is Put-in-Bay’s women’s resort wear boutique that brings you the latest summer fashions. We have a wide selection of women’s resort apparel, shoes, hand bags, jewelry, novelty tee shirts and accessories. Our favorite lines include Columbia, Lulu B, Sperry and Buddy By the Lake. Need a swim-suit, sunscreen and sunglasses ,we got you covered. Shop our friendly atmosphere at Misty Bay Boutique. Our store front patio is pet friendly and is connected to a fun Round House patio bar. Lake Erie visitors love to shop & enjoy a bevy!

The Sweetest Bar on the island lives up to its name selling homemade fudge by the slice, hand-dipped chocolates, cookies and treats, old fashion candies, novelty candies, taffy and movie-size favorites among other treats. The PIB Candy Bar also serves a full compliment of scooped and soft-serve ice cream, including a selection of cones, sundaes and shakes. Ranked in the “Top 5 Confection Destinations” on Lake Erie, and the only confectionary ranked in Ohio.

Put-in-Bay Surf Shop is the only place on the island where you can find name brand swimwear & apparel. Featured brands are Roxy, Quiksilver, Billabong, O'Neill, SunBum, Reef and Sanuk. You will find a wide selection of the best quality Put-in-Bay apparel at this great shop. Hats, koozies, stickers, pint glasses, shot glasses, t-shirts, sweatshirts, outerwear, sunscreen, sunglasses, jewelry, and even longboards! We are the only shop offering Mojito Bay stickers, hats and apparel as well.

The Picnic Basket is a shop that's tucked in next to the Boathouse Bar & Grill and offers unique gift items and custom made baskets for a special occasion or date night.

The Shop at the Top offers unique educational gifts including gemstones, geodes, and science kits. Fun toys and games. Souvenirs and Unique Jewelry. Purchase Gemstone Mining Rough Mix and Geodes for Cutting in the Shop! Purchase Rounds of War of 18 Holes Miniature Golf at Caddyshack by hole #1 or in the Shop! Purchase Fort aMAZE’n Time Cards at booth in front of maze or in the Shop! Purchase Rock Climbing tickets in the Shop!